Can We Please Avoid Over-Engineering - YAGNI

YAGNI Principle in Software Engineering

As software engineers, we all have a tendency to plan for the future. We often add features or complexity to the codebase in anticipation of future needs. However, this leads to bloated, hard-to-maintain software that complicates the development cycle.

YAGNI (You Ain't Gonna Need It) principle teaches us to avoid this trap by only building what’s necessary now.

If you want daily career growth content on IG, follow hemant_careerbytes

TLDR (Collaboration)

---

Don’t get time to follow the latest tech, programming and coding news ?

Try TLDR’s free daily newsletter

TLDR covers the most interesting tech, science, and coding news in just 5 minutes

---

What is YAGNI?

YAGNI is a principle from Extreme Programming (XP) that encourages developers to avoid implementing features unless there is an immediate, real need for them. Instead of guessing what might be needed later, developers should focus on solving the current problem. This leads to simpler, more maintainable code.

Benefits of YAGNI

1. Enhanced Maintainability: A smaller codebase is easier to understand and maintain.

2. Improved Performance: Fewer unnecessary features reduce performance bottlenecks.

3. Reduced Technical Debt: Avoiding unneeded complexity now reduces potential future rewrites.

Let’s take an example in which we want to implement local caching

Now, let’s look at code below

Did you find anything ?

The code above shows a cache class preparing for distributed caching, even though it's not needed in the current requirements. The added complexity makes the code harder to maintain and debug, without providing any immediate benefit.

Now, if we implement the YAGNI rule, it would be much simpler

Here, we only implement local caching, which is sufficient for current needs. If scaling becomes an issue later, we can introduce a distributed cache at that point.

You will find multiple examples in your codebase as well where developers over-engineer APIs to anticipate future needs, add excessive abstraction layers that don’t provide immediate value. Some of the common pitfalls are:

• Over-Anticipating Future Requirements
  It’s easy to fall into the trap of trying to predict every future requirement. Instead, you should adapt the codebase as needed.

• Over-Designing
  Over abstraction might seem flexible, but it often complicate the system. Keep designs simple until there’s a clear reason to add complexity.

• Premature Scalability
  Don’t build for scalability unless it’s already a concern. Focus on making the system work well now, and scale when necessary.

Applying YAGNI to your Codebase

Some of the common ways to apply YAGNI to your existing codebase

• Identify Unused Code
  Use static analysis tools to find dead code or features that are never used.

• Remove Unused Features
  Safely remove code that doesn’t contribute to current functionality.

• Write Tests
  Ensure the refactored system continues to work by adding or updating test coverage.

By following YAGNI, you can create lean, efficient software that adapts to change.

The YAGNI principle encourages developers like us to focus on what’s important now, reduce complexity, improve maintainability, and keep technical debt minimal.

I added new tab “Free Resources” on my newsletter home page. Do checkout if you didn’t get a chance yet.